Mahler’s Reorchestration of Beethoven’s 9th and the Aesthetic of the Colossal

Level of Education of Students Involved

Undergraduate

Faculty Sponsor

Katharina Uhde

College

College of Arts & Sciences (CAS)

Discipline(s)

Music, Musicology, Music History

Presentation Type

Oral Presentation

Symposium Date

Spring 2026

Abstract

The aesthetic of the "colossal", which scholars including Craig Wright (Yale, 2012), Elizabeth A. Wells, Owain Arwel Hughes, and others have linked to Mahler's aesthetic at large, is an apt descriptor of Mahler's daring reorchestration of Beethoven's 9th Symphony -- a reimagined work featuring various changes in orchestration, dynamics, doubling, and counter-melodic material.

This research builds on the scholarly research of Denis McCaldin, Robert Samuels, and Hans F. Redlich, as well as on the popular-musicological research by Craig Wright and Marcelo Uzcátegui Andrade, to show that Mahler's reimagination of Beethoven's 9th was born out of a deep and multi-layered fascination with the aesthetic of the colossal. Indeed, Mahler's approach, paying great respect to Beethoven while having moved into a significantly modernized age in which the institutionalization of music impacted all areas of life -- including much larger orchestras filling much larger concert halls -- fitted right in with the state of modernization of classical music at the time.

On the one hand, this research describes in detail the changes that musicologists have traced in the first movement of Mahler's reorchestration in comparison with Beethoven's 9th, and on the other hand this research ties Mahler's work to its cultural context -- the aesthetic of the colossal in Vienna around the turn of the century -- thereby throwing light on precedents, possible inspirations, as well as practical considerations Mahler may have contemplated.

Biographical Information about Author(s)

Olivia Sobel is a Junior Music Education Major from Elburn, Illinois. She is currently studying violin with Dr. Diego Piedra and performs in the symphony orchestra (violin/viola), chamber concert band (trumpet), and in various chamber ensembles. As a Valparaiso University concerto competition winner, she performed Mozart's Violin Concerto No. 5, Allegro Aperto, in the spring of 2025 with the VU Symphony Orchestra. Outside of this, she is a substitute violinist for the LaPorte County Symphony Orchestra. 

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS